When Life Takes Away Who We Used to Be

|November 13th, 2026|Emotional Health|

There are losses in life that do not involve the death of another person, yet they can leave us grieving deeply. Retirement, aging, and chronic illness often bring such losses. What disappears is not simply a job, a physical ability, or a familiar routine. We may also lose relationships, communities, and the reassuring experience of belonging somewhere. Sometimes, what we lose is a part of ourselves.

A nurse retires after forty years of practice and discovers that the freedom once anticipated feels strangely empty. An older person begins needing assistance with ordinary tasks. A patient with chronic kidney disease can no longer work, travel spontaneously, or participate in familiar social activities. Each may confront a disturbing question: Who am I now that I can no longer be who I was?

We construct our identities gradually, often without realizing how dependent they become on what we do, whom we know, and where we belong. Our occupations, relationships, physical abilities, and daily routines provide more than structure. They offer continuity, recognition, and a sense of personal worth. The teacher is accustomed to being needed. The nurse is motivated by  caring for someone in need. The member of a community feels recognized through shared experiences. Over time, these experiences become woven into our sense of self.

When circumstances remove them, the resulting distress may be difficult to explain. Outsiders see retirement as an opportunity, aging as a natural process, or medical treatment as a necessary adjustment. Yet the individual may experience these transitions as the disappearance of a familiar world.

Retirement is frequently presented as a reward for decades of effort. But for individuals whose professional identity has become central to their self-esteem, retirement can provoke feelings of emptiness and diminished significance. The retired nurse may miss not only clinical responsibilities but also colleagues, shared conversations, and spontaneous encounters. The workplace was more than a place of employment. It was a community in which the individual occupied a recognizable position.

From a psychodynamic perspective, professional life serves important narcissistic and relational functions. It reinforces self-worth and provides the experience of being valued by others. When this world disappears, the individual may lose both a source of self-esteem and relationships that supported their identity. Retirement may therefore require mourning not only an occupation but also a community to which one belonged.

Aging introduces another form of loss, often gradual and difficult to acknowledge. Physical capacities change. Independence may diminish. Activities once performed effortlessly require assistance. But aging also transforms the social world. Friends retire, relocate, become ill, or die. Familiar gatherings become less frequent. Communities that once provided continuity may disappear. For someone accustomed to independence and social connection, these changes may evoke shame, loneliness, and feelings of invisibility. Aging confronts us not only with the limits of the body but also with the fragility of belonging.

Chronic illness can accelerate these psychological challenges. For patients with chronic kidney disease, fatigue, medical appointments, dietary restrictions, dialysis schedules, and physical limitations can interfere with employment, friendships, and community participation. A patient may stop attending gatherings because of exhaustion. Another may withdraw because explaining treatment requirements feels uncomfortable. Someone receiving dialysis may find participation in family life increasingly difficult.

Gradually, invitations become less frequent. Friends lose contact. Former colleagues move on. The patient may feel forgotten by a world that continues without them. We recognize ourselves partly through the eyes of others. Familiar people remember our history, acknowledge our abilities, and confirm that we occupy a meaningful place in their lives. When these connections weaken, the patient loses more than companionship. Important sources of psychological continuity disappear. Medical stability does not necessarily resolve this suffering. A patient may have acceptable laboratory results while experiencing profound loneliness.

Freud understood mourning as a process through which emotional attachments to what has been lost are gradually reorganized. In retirement, aging, and illness, the lost self may be an earlier version of oneself, a valued role, or an entire community of relationships. Anger may conceal helplessness. Withdrawal may protect against anticipated rejection. Nostalgia may preserve connections with a valued past. Psychotherapeutic work can help these experiences become understandable. Before a new sense of identity and belonging can develop, what has been lost often needs to be recognized and mourned.

Psychological adaptation does not require forgetting who we were. The retired nurse may discover meaningful connections beyond professional status. The aging individual may find new forms of participation. The person living with kidney disease may reclaim relationships that illness has disrupted, sometimes in surprising places such as the dialysis waiting room. These possibilities do not erase grief. Families, healthcare professionals, and communities also have a role in preserving connection and meaningful participation.

We need more than physical survival. We need to feel that we matter to others, that our presence is recognized, and that we continue to belong. Perhaps the deepest pain of retirement, aging, or illness is not simply losing what we once did. It is losing the people and communities through which we knew who we were. And perhaps healing begins when we discover that, even as our roles and capacities change, there can still be a place for us in the lives of others.

About the Author

Dr Gavril Hercz

Dr. Gavril Hercz is a nephrologist at Hennick Humber Hospital and Associate Professor of Medicine, University of Toronto. He completed his psychoanalytic training at the Toronto Psychoanalytic Institute and is a member of the Canadian Psychoanalytic Society. His major area of interest is the impact of physical illness on patients, families, and caregivers.

We need more than physical survival. We need to feel that we matter to others, that our presence is recognized, and that we continue to belong.